This is my first time reading the comments on this site and that was a good, seemingly well-researched discussion on a topic I know almost nothing about and tend to avoid because it worries me (I know that's a poor habit). I give it 8/10: better than any youtube discussion but not as thorough as a month-long correspondence of essays might be.
you already gave me gold with the no good games after 2004 comment
Oh that was Im_CIA? I don't know if you still stand by that but I love the idea of saying "Yeah, they can never top this" and never looking back.