GUYS! yes! I love it, I'm a huge fan of horror stuff. I listen to them mostly on YT, if you don't know, LazyMasquarade is my favourite. I also like MrNightmare, MrCreepyPasta, KingSpook, ScareTeather...
If you are fan of Tat's I'd tottally reccomand you ReignBotHorror's vids too: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCchWU8ta6L-Dy3rGIxPINzw
Also SomeOrdinaryGamers has good content too as well.
I can't name my fav creepypasta, there is too much of them, but so far on of my favourite was this long one about mysterious stairs in the woods
it's like mix of most american horror creatures and combines them all in nice mystery. I also love "Gateway of the mind", definitelly one of the one that might not be scary, but stays with you for long time...
From gaming creepypastas... I like "Ben Drowned" and "Polybius" but the one that actually made me feel uncomfortable was "jvk1166z.esp" probably because I'm taken by nostalgia of the game and I remember morrowind sometimes used to scare me when I played it as a kid, so it added to the effect.
Also I will confess I like the whole idea for Herobrine (along with other MC spooky stuff) and how even creators joke about removing him with every update.
And how hard players want to summon those stuff in game.